Sunday, June 17, 2018

Why factually these United States is a more perfect Union, not a country, nation, or state

One cannot understand the range of emotions experienced - and related opinions held - by Americans, without having an awareness of the world of the men we call the Founding Fathers of the United States. Particularly, we need to understand the language they spoke, the meaning of the words they used. Late 18th Century Colonial English might seem to resemble the language of 21st Century America, but it is not the same language. 

Political disinformation in the United States for 230 years has created confusion about certain words important to an understanding about what was new and different in the world after the Revolutionary War.

Key to the confusion is the American jumbling together of words that once had truly different definitions and implications - country, nation, state, and union.

For purposes of clarity and simplicity, as used here from this point on the following words have specific meanings based upon pre-17th Century concepts:
  • "Country" means "any considerable territory demarcated by topographical conditions."
  • "Nation" means "any distinctive population with a common language, culture, and considerable history."
  • "State" means "a central civil government or authority that exercises the legitimate use of force within defined geographical boundaries."
  • "Union" means "a number of states or nations joined together for defined purposes to be accomplished by a separately created autonomous authority."
Using those definitions, the Cherokee Nation is a nation. Italy is a country and a state. Japan is a country, a state, and a nation. The United States of America is none of these. It is a union of states.

 

It's not a country - here's why


Again, "country" as will be used here means "any considerable territory demarcated by topographical conditions."

As explained in Wikipedia:

    In English the word has increasingly become associated with political divisions, so that one sense, associated with the indefinite article – "a country" – through misuse and subsequent conflation is now a synonym for state, or a former sovereign state, in the sense of sovereign territory or "district, native land"....
    The equivalent terms in French and other Romance languages (pays and variants) have not carried the process of being identified with political sovereign states as far as the English "country".... In many European countries the words are used for sub-divisions of the national territory, as in the German Bundesländer, as well as a less formal term for a sovereign state. France has very many "pays" that are officially recognised at some level, and are either natural regions, like the Pays de Bray, or reflect old political or economic entities, like the Pays de la Loire.
    A version of "country" can be found in the modern French language as contrée, based on the word cuntrée in Old French, that is used similarly to the word "pays" to define non-state regions, but can also be used to describe a political state in some particular cases. The modern Italian contrada is a word with its meaning varying locally, but usually meaning a ward or similar small division of a town, or a village or hamlet in the countryside.

For purposes of sharing an understanding of the political world as understood by our Founding Fathers, here is a map of Europe at the time of the creation of the United States of America:



Fundamentally, Europe was divided into constantly warring empires with shifting boundaries. While topographical conditions may have slowed some conquests, our concept of "country" did not set boundaries for kingdoms and empires which are "states" by our definitions. And that was an attitude that Europeans brought to the Americas and which has resulted in a blurring of the terms "country" and "state."

As can be seen on the map below, North America is a large geographic area with significant topographical conditions:
Click on image to see a larger version!

If a people whose only mode of transportation on land is walking "discover" such a geographic area and through walking logically divide it into more than one division without intent, it is reasonable to assume that the dominate shape for divisions would most likely be in a north-to-south direction,  more or less. And indeed, the result of an actual natural migration produced this map:


Further some predominantly English-speaking Europeans came along and, initially struggling just to survive, began to occupy a land bounded by topography:



But these folks were Europeans used to warring empires with shifting boundaries not constrained by topography. So over the next 150 years in defiance of the idea of a topographically-defined "country" they and their descendants drew some lines dividing that continental topography in illogical ways...


... and, more irrationally, even further like this:


To summarize, the United States is not a "country" defined by obvious topographical extremes. Even the oceans did not stop it from including Hawaii as one of the internal "state" governments even though it is 2,500 miles from the American Continent. In fact, the Rocky Mountains were known as the Continental Divide but even that didn't suggest creating separate "countries" based on topography. The United States is not a country as we define it.

 

It's not a nation - here's why


As it will be used here "nation" means "any distinctive population with a common language, culture, and considerable history." And it is this map that indicates a division of the North  American Continent by "nations" of indigenous peoples...


As already discussed, the American "melting pot" did not include those indigenous North American nations, African slaves and their descendants, and the indigenous Spanish speaking residents of lands purchased or conquered by the United States. Not only that, the United States encouraged immigration from around the world, such as from China to build the Transcontinental Railroad, resulting in these maps today...


...which makes it very clear that the United States is not a "nation" by our definition as "any distinctive population with a common language, culture, and considerable history."

As a reminder, as explored in another post Saving the Union is a struggle against pots, bowls, and mosaics, between individuality, identity, and assimilation, amid unprecedented wealth disparity the historical fact that the term "melting pot" was a concept to encourage immigrant "English, Scotch, Irish, French, Dutch, Germans, and Swedes" who back home in Europe constantly fought wars with each other to form an English-speaking culture. Had anyone before 1920 suggested adding other races, they would have been met with incredulous laughter.

So it is a perfectly logical outcome of this history that emotionally for many within the United States "nationalism" means only white English-speaking nationalism. But that doesn't reflect the population born and living here.

Again the United States is not a "nation."
 

It is not a state but rather a union - here's why


As it will be used here "state" means "a central civil government or authority that exercises the legitimate use of force within defined geographical boundaries." Given the definitions accepted here, most would want to say the United States is a "state."

Except, of course, within the defined geographical boundary that is the United States pursuant to Constitutional law there are 50+ "state" governments which independently exercise the legitimate use of force within defined internal geographical boundaries. There is nothing confusing about the wording of the 10th Amendment to the Constitution:
    The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
So the United States is not even a "state" in the our use of the word (for this discussion entering into the arguments over the so-called "implied powers" is not relevant). Rather, it is a "union" which means "a number of states or nations joined together for defined purposes to be accomplished by a separately created autonomous authority." The following is the Preamble of the Constitution of the United States (emphasis added):
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
And here is where the confusion exists. In that document, the Constitution of the United States, a "Union" was formed. That "Union" meant "a number of states or nations joined together for defined purposes to be accomplished by a separately created autonomous authority."

The existing real states jointly assigned the Union the limited authority to use a very few of their powers and functions while retaining the vast balance of powers of a state to themselves.

Americans seem to be confused about that. Perhaps that is because political history is not something we think is as important as, say, how to use technology to see cat videos to make us laugh. But sometimes we need to consider the concept of a "union" in the context of the American Revolution and Constitution which happened in the last quarter of the 17th Century. It literally was all the latest in government.

"Founding Father" Benjamin Franklin was born in 1706 which meant that even our oldest Founding Father had a clear understanding of the then new, cool British concept of a "union." That is because over the first two years of Franklin's life the concept of a political "union" was formalized during the process of creating Great Britain which most Americans probably think was created by the Romans at the time Jesus was alive.

Wikipedia provides a brief insight into what we frequently shorten to Britain:
    The Kingdom of Scotland emerged as an independent sovereign state in the Early Middle Ages and continued to exist until 1707. By inheritance in 1603, James VI, King of Scots, became King of England and King of Ireland, thus forming a personal union of the three kingdoms. Scotland subsequently entered into a political union with the Kingdom of England on 1 May 1707 to create the new Kingdom of Great Britain. The union also created a new Parliament of Great Britain, which succeeded both the Parliament of Scotland and the Parliament of England. In 1801, Great Britain itself entered into a political union with the Kingdom of Ireland to create the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland.
    Within Scotland, the monarchy of the United Kingdom has continued to use a variety of styles, titles and other royal symbols of statehood specific to the pre-union Kingdom of Scotland. The legal system within Scotland has also remained separate from those of England and Wales and Northern Ireland; Scotland constitutes a distinct jurisdiction in both public and private law. The continued existence of legal, educational, religious and other institutions distinct from those in the remainder of the UK have all contributed to the continuation of Scottish culture and national identity since the 1707 union with England.
    In 1997, a Scottish Parliament was re-established, in the form of a devolved unicameral legislature comprising 129 members, having authority over many areas of domestic policy....
In a different Wikipedia entry we can also learn:
    The Acts of Union were two Acts of Parliament: the Union with Scotland Act 1706 passed by the Parliament of England, and the Union with England Act passed in 1707 by the Parliament of Scotland. They put into effect the terms of the Treaty of Union that had been agreed on 22 July 1706, following negotiation between commissioners representing the parliaments of the two countries. By the two Acts, the Kingdom of England and the Kingdom of Scotland—which at the time were separate states with separate legislatures, but with the same monarch—were, in the words of the Treaty, "United into One Kingdom by the Name of Great Britain".
    The Acts took effect on 1 May 1707. On this date, the Scottish Parliament and the English Parliament united to form the Parliament of Great Britain, based in the Palace of Westminster in London, the home of the English Parliament. Hence, the Acts are referred to as the Union of the Parliaments. On the Union, the historian Simon Schama said "What began as a hostile merger, would end in a full partnership in the most powerful going concern in the world ... it was one of the most astonishing transformations in European history."
It might surprise many that within the Constitution of the United States the term "country" never appears. The term "nation" appears only in reference to "Commerce with foreign Nations" and to "punish Piracies and Felonies committed on the high Seas, and Offences against the Law of Nations." The term "state" does appear, but always in reference to the proposed union of 13 states - you know, the real states per our definition which was the definition understood by Benjamin Franklin and the other Founding Fathers.

On the other hand, besides in the preamble quoted above, the term "union" is used as follows:
  • New States may be admitted by the Congress into this Union...
    The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government...
  • He shall from time to time give to the Congress Information of the State of the Union...
  • Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers...
  • To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union...
In the lifetime of the "Founding Fathers" prior to the Revolutionary War, Great Britain was clearly understood to be newly created as a "union" which was a revolutionary acknowledgement of a political idea. Because of the words used in the Constitution, it would be fair to say that the United States was created as a "union" of somewhat diverse states, where "state" clearly referenced 13 central civil governments that exercised the legitimate use of force within 13 defined geographical boundaries. This shouldn't come as a surprise, as for the Founding Fathers a "union" was a new and improved concept of political organization.

And is it surprising that the winning army in the Civil War was the Union Army? Was not the Union Army a land force that fought to keep and preserve the Union of the collective states? Did you never wonder why they called it the "Union" army?

In fact throughout the 19th Century, the Union was known as "these United States" which is a plural designation meaning more than one state. Titus Munson Coan who in his 1875 article "A New Country" in which he coined the term "Melting Pot" uses "these United States are" a decade after the end of the Civil War while trying to argue that it is a country, though what became the American Melting Pot "transforms the English, the German, the Irish emigrant into an American" creating a "great nation of Christendom."

Coan's piece was written after the 1849 approval of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo ending the Mexican-American War, which permits Spanish-speaking brown folks to remain in the United States entitling them "to the enjoyment of all the rights of citizens of the United States, according to the principles of the Constitution; and in the mean time, shall be maintained and protected in the free enjoyment of their liberty and property, and secured in the free exercise of their religion without; restriction." Coan's piece was written after the Civil War when the slaves were freed and the 14th Amendment to the Constitution was adopted which begins: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside." But Coan had no confusion about who is in the American "nation" which is similar to most today's Americans of European descent living in the Red States indicated above.

But still, Coan wrote "these United States."

Linguist Mark Liberman in When did the Supreme Court make us an 'is'? noted that, contrary to one of his previous posts indicating the change to "the United States is" may have been made after the Civil War, he learned that Minor Myers of the Brooklyn Law School prepared a study Supreme Court Usage and the Making of an 'Is' which examined the use of the phrases “United States is” and “United States are” in opinions of the United States Supreme Court from 1790 to 1919 and determined that the plural usage was the predominant usage in the 1870s, 1880s, and 1890s and did not disappear until the 1920's.

As one comment speculated it is likely the plural persisted "at least through Reconstruction, and I'm afraid it hasn't entirely disappeared in some quarters."

No it it hasn't disappeared, and sometimes the use of the plural in the 21st Century creates a political buzz. For example, on Thursday, April 25, 2013, speaking at the dedication of the George W. Bush Library,  then President Barack Obama asked God to bless "these United States."

Don't dismiss this as if it were Bush fumbling a speech. Obama taught constitutional law at the University of Chicago Law School for twelve years. In his 2013 inaugural address he closed with "Thank you, God Bless you, and may He forever bless these United States of America." Obama understands that those who drafted the Constitution never intended that the Union be other than "these states." When he says "these" states Constitutional Law professor Obama knows full well that it is "these" states that make up a Union.

Again, the singular usage "the United States is" did not become the "common" form until after World War I when it became obvious that the Union functioned as an "is" in a complex international scene where people could kill each other in the millions based on their "is-ness."

We need to understand "these United States" is a union created solely for purposes of a common military defense and assuring economic success of the numerous and separate states, not regulate mundane issues such as who can have sex with whom. That's one reason why in 1792 Americans insisted on leaving establishing government churches to the real states.

Friday, June 15, 2018

Three Californias - it was interesting to contemplate in the abstract but would be a signficant gamble

In June 2005 the Three Californias website was created:


The front page above explains why the website was created.

As of June 13, 2018, an initiative ballot measure to split California into three states qualified for the ballot according to the California Secretary of State.

[Because the measure proposes to create one of the states as "California", for clarity I'll use in this post the designations for the three new states that appear on the measure's website "NorCal", "SoCal", and "Cal" while continuing to use "California" for the existing state.]

The headlines that resulted from the certification of the measure by the Secretary of State were predictable:
The top headline is a reasonably balanced AP story.

The second headline in Bloomberg News is not true, apparently written by someone who is uninformed. It isn't Tim Draper's dream proposal. His dream proposal first advanced in 2014 was to divide California into six states. He failed to qualify that measure for the ballot.

The last phrase of the third headline above - seen as unlikely - is not a foregone conclusion. 

Draper's proposal if approved by the voters has a chance despite major interest group opposition. And it appears it will be the only chance to redesign state and local government for the next century. As noted in the AP story:

    Backers of the measure argue California has become "ungovernable" because of its economic and geographic diversity as well as its population approaching 40 million people.
    The measure aims to create states with relatively equal populations and economic strengths.
    Draper argues that California has become "nearly ungovernable" because of its diverse economies and population. He and backers also argue that voters outside of large urban areas such as Los Angeles are underserved in Sacramento because so many state lawmakers come from major cities.
    "Breaking the state into three smaller, more manageable states means those states will be more responsible and more responsive," said Peggy Grande, a Cal 3 spokeswoman.

Draper learned from his mistakes in 2014 and appears to have examined how to design a measure. With that said, the chance to make its way through all the legal and political hurdles that splitting an existing state faces will depend entirely on unrelated occurrences. For instance, the consideration of the idea by Congress in the 1850's following California's admission to the Union was halted by the Civil War. And an effort in the 1930's was ended by WWII.

Draper's Cal 3 website offers a summary of the three states in terms of economics and population:


Among the 52 states, instead of being the largest in population SoCal would be #4 and NoCal would be #5 behind Texas, Florida, and New York followed by Illinois and Pennsylvania with Cal being #8.

Among the 52 states, instead of California being the third largest in area behind Alaska and Texas, SoCal would be #16, NorCal would be #20, and Cal would be #43.

Among the 52 states, instead of California have the largest economy by far, NorCal would rank #3 behind Texas and New York, with Cal ranked #6 and SoCal #9.

However, instead of ranking #9 in per capita personal income, NorCal would be ranked #2 behind only Connecticut (retaining very significant income disparity), while Cal would be #12 (with similar disparities), and SoCal would be #30 (below the national average).

The question for Californians is whether they want to continue things the way they are for their state and local government well into the 21st Century or completely redesign their government. This isn't about identity, it is about the statistical truths as explained on the Cal 3 website. 

The fact is the misinformation campaign has already started in the press. In an article in the Sacramento Bee we are told: "A tech billionaire's proposal to split California into three states would, at least in the short term, likely put more Democrats in the U.S. Senate, according to a Bee review of voter registration and election data." And we are offered these graphs:

Those graphs are statistically accurate. But in the 2008 election in which Obama won in all three of the proposed new states, Proposition 8 Banning Gay Marriage won in SoCal with a 61.6%  "yes" vote and won in Cal with a 50.1% "yes" vote. It was defeated only in NorCal with a 50.1% "no" vote. So at the same time Cal voters were overwhelmingly voting for Obama, they voted to ban gay marriage.

And the 2004 Presidential Election results looked like this:

In other words, it is not possible to predict what the political orientation of the new three states would be except to say SoCal is likely to lean Republican and conservative.

Most importantly, we must remember that established institutions will oppose the measure.

The initiative measure to divide the state isn't exactly the same as our 2005 proposal as can be seen in this graphic:

Several key differences are troublesome. The 2005 proposal attempts to keep geographic regions together including the Southwestern-desert-climate influenced counties of Southern California and the counties of the Central Valley as defined by the Sierra Nevada watershed on the west and the Coast Range watershed on the east. The 2005 recommendation included a Coastal California based on keeping fisheries and other Pacific Ocean features together. Dividing the coastline in the middle of the Monterey Bay and at the Los Angeles County/Orange County line is troublesome.

Frankly, with the Trump administration wanting to open the coastline to oil drilling and challenging California's strong historical ties to Mexico and Asia, it seems risky to divide the state. Politically the Calexit proposal would give the State more clout in dealing with the United States government.

Then there are the cultural concerns. Probably no other statistics can tell us more about gut-level cultural differences than the 2008 results on Proposition 8 - The California Marriage Protection Act which eliminated the rights of same-sex couples to marry until overturned by a court. Here is a comparison of the results of that election if the state were split under our 2005 proposal versus the 2018 ballot measure:


Using the Proposition 8 vote as tea leaves, one could conclude that the 2018 Initiative split would leave NorCal and Cal each with a liberal/conservative cultural split of about 50/50, creating two states with potentially significant hard-to-resolve cultural conflicts. SoCal would have a conservative cultural attitude.

Our 2005 Proposal was designed to create a NorCal with a conservative cultural attitude and a Coastal California with a liberal cultural attitude. SoCal would lean conservative.

One could argue that the 2018 initiative would force the two sides in NorCal and Cal to learn to work through differences. But it would leave both very vulnerable to influence from the Koch political network. It could be possible that instead of a large Blue State California being a bastion of liberal thought, two of the three states would become swing states while one would be Republican.

In other words, upon the implementation of the Cal 3 initiative, many California residents could find themselves in a state that has a different majority political and cultural orientation than exists today.

And that's the problem with making such a significant change. Again, it appears Draper's initiative  will be the only chance to redesign California state and local government for the next century.  But it is almost impossible to make any valid forecasts about the outcome of those changes.

Since two prior attempts at splitting the state were ended by the Civil War and WWII, it gives one a sense of foreboding. And yet, we do know that California is nearly ungovernable because of its large and diverse economy, population, and geography. In fact, "they" knew that back in 1850.

Saturday, June 2, 2018

"...As America focuses west"
  The American military embraces the Indo-Pacific
  worldview advocated in posts here for ten years


On May 30, 2018, Defense Secretary Jim Mattis announced in Hawaii that the Pentagon is changing the name of the Pacific Command to the U.S. Indo-Pacific Command.

With the USS Arizona Memorial behind him, Mattis said:

    For U.S. Pacific Command, it is our primary combatant command, it's standing watch and intimately engaged with over half of the earth's surface and its diverse populations, from Hollywood to Bollywood, from polar bears to penguins as Admiral Harris puts it.
    Having grown up in Washington state, one of five American states with Pacific Ocean coastlines and looking out the plane's window yesterday coming across that vast expanse of ocean, in my flight here I was reminded that the United States is today and has been for two centuries a Pacific nation.
    Further, in recognition of the increasing connectivity, the Indian and Pacific Oceans, today we rename the U.S. Pacific Command to U.S. Indo-Pacific Command. Over many decades, this command has repeatedly adapted to changing circumstance, and today carries that legacy forward as America focuses west.

Beginning in the last quarter of the 20th Century, the Defense Department has moved in a timely manner to recognize all significant changes in the world.

For instance, in May 1990 the U.S. Naval War College issued a 73-page report titled “Global Climate Change Implications for the United States.” The report found that Naval operations in the coming half century may be drastically affected by the impact of global climate change.In 2008 it added climate change to its 32-page National Defense Strategy stating: “[C]hanges with existing and future resource, environmental, and climate pressures may generate new security challenges ... These risks will require managing the divergent needs of massively increasing energy demand to maintain economic development and the need to tackle climate change.”

The Mattis announcement indicates a shift in view "as American focuses west." Consider for a moment these two maps:


If you embrace a pre-21st Century American view of the world shown in the top map, you sail East to the Indian Ocean, a very Mediterranean-Atlantic worldview. If you embrace a 21st Century American view of the world shown in the bottom map, you sail West to the Indian Ocean, a very Indo-Pacific worldview.

The latter is the worldview advocated here since the first post Limited Time Only - Act now to own your piece of the Pacific Ocean off the Mendocino Coast in 2008 and specifically this year in History Matters: The 2016 Bi-Partisan Attack on the Pacific States People, Beliefs, Economy, Defense in which it was noted, among other things, that in 2016 both national political parties embraced a policy of failure to provide defense planning to protect the Pacific States because of that outdated Mediterranean-Atlantic worldview.

The problem is, of course, the major mainstream newspapers, magazines, and TV news are all based in Atlantic Seaboard locations and have not yet realized that Europe has already switched places with Asia in world importance - meaning we either have to quit focusing on England, France, Germany, Italy, etc., or join them in the future in a less than 1st World status.

We need to understand that Americans don't sail east to India anymore. Fortunately, the Pentagon has figured that out. Now if the rest of America could learn to face west....

Saturday, May 5, 2018


What reporters and you cannot learn from Twitter about the three redwoods or China's plans for their children's economic well-being in 2035 and 2049

Five posts here give the reader a peek into the reality of 21st Century China. The intent was to give the reader a start to catch up to Warren Buffet on the matter of China.

Just before the beginning of the new millennium, Warren Buffett was watching China. He also was buying suits from Li Guilian, chairwoman of Dayang Trands, the Dalian-based menswear manufacturer. And he persuaded his friend Bill Gates and others to do so.

In fact, in a February 1996 Harvard Business Review piece What I Learned from Warren Buffett, near the beginning Bill Gates notes: "We recently vacationed together in China with our wives."

But sadly over the next twenty years Buffett had the economic ideologues who make up the American press and much of the business community baffled about his investments in China.

In addition to investing in smaller companies that were opening operations in China, in 2003 there was this New York Times headline Investors Ponder Buffett's Move Into China Oil. And in September of 2008 MidAmerican Energy, 87.4 per cent owned by Mr. Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway, acquired a 10 per cent stake in BYD, a Chinese electric carmaker and rechargeable battery producer which led to this story in the British publication The Telegraph a year later Warren Buffett's support helps make Wang Chuanfu China's richest man which notes "Mr Wang has been feted around the world after BYD beat major manufacturers, such as Toyota and General Motors, to build a new generation electric hybrid car."

In February this year a CNBC story noted that "the 87-year-old chairman and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, dubbed gǔshén ("god of stocks") in Mandarin, permeates consumer, cultural, philanthropic and media domains" in China and:

    Some 3,000 Chinese descended on Omaha for last year's Berkshire Hathaway shareholder meeting, which was also live-streamed and rebroadcast on a loop in China. The festivities are translated into only one foreign language: Mandarin.
    The world has many rich people, and China alone has almost 600 billionaires. What differentiates Warren Buffett for the Chinese public, however, is how he accumulated his wealth: with intelligence, not inheritance.

This week from an interview Warren Buffett: China has ‘found a secret sauce for themselves’ we learned:

    Warren Buffett, known as the “god of stocks” in China, speaks highly of the country’s economic growth and is optimistic about its future.
    “What they’ve done in the last 50 or 60 years is a total economic miracle. I never would’ve thought it could’ve happened,” Buffett told Yahoo Finance’s Andy Serwer in Omaha earlier this year. “What I do know is they have found a secret sauce for themselves, just like we found the secret sauce a couple centuries ago.”
    Buffett says “countries will do it differently,” referring to the fundamental differences between China and the U.S. politically and economically. China’s state capitalism emphasizes economic growth and social stability, with tight control over domestic politics and information. Since the economic reform in 1978, China has grown at a staggering pace of 9.5% per year and has become the world’s second largest economy. In the past five years, China’s GDP growth has slowed down but still achieved an increase of 6.9% last year, dwarfing America’s 2.3% increase.
    And Buffett believes China’s growth story is far from over.

And, of course, online reader comments on the piece by Americans show just how little most know about 21st Century China. You might think that at least the American business press would provide China coverage. But in the U.S. there is a child-like focus on yesterday's profits, the shiny prize in the Happy Meal of the "me" culture. It is sad only because the adults in the room in China have been and are focused economically on assuring a future of economic well-being of people under the age of 30 in the years 2020, 2035, and 2049.

In October 2017 the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China (CPC) was held, a once-every-five-years gathering. In March 2018 the "Two Sessions", or lianghui, or simultaneous sessions was held which were the first session of five annual plenary sessions of the 13th National People's Congress (NPC), and the 13th National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC). In April 2018 The Boao Forum for Asia Annual Conference was held.

Together these events represented an important opportunity for the American press to inform Americans about what's going on in China's economic sphere. Much of what little coverage was offered was colored by bias and ignorance.

It will matter to your children and grandchildren if Americans remain closed to accepting China as a viable nation with a government dedicated to the well-being of its people. Right now, depending upon whose numbers you use, China is either the largest economy in the world or the second largest. But regardless of which statistical system you prefer, China is the most populous country and by 2049 China will be the largest economy in the world by a wide margin. That most certainly will affect your children and grandchildren.

This series of posts coincide with the third annual CHINAWEEK event in Los Angeles. On Thursday California Governor Jerry Brown again offered the keynote address.

Urging greater cooperation with China, Brown said: "We all learn from each other and globalization is here. We are not going to get rid of it. And a trade war is stupid. No tariff, no little trade dispute or big trade dispute is going to stop us. The stuff that's not working today, let's figure out how to make it work."

While California’s large and diverse economy (the world's 5th largest economy surpassed only by the total GDP of the United States without California, China, Japan and Germany) tends to insulate it from President Trump's trade war, nonetheless 287,000 jobs could be lost in businesses targeted by Chinese tariffs threatened in response to U.S. tariff increases — more than any other state.

Noting that the two countries have great potential as future trade partners, Brown said "all you need is a great leader." Brown assured the business leaders that "this too will pass. I'm not telling you what I'm referring to."

Still, Americans find it easy to dismiss Brown as he is a politician. Which brings us to the point of this series of posts.

Economics are complicated and what you don't know about your competitor is the surest way to lose. The Chinese are planning for economic success through 2049. Most American companies are arguing over yesterday's P&L results.

Not all American business leaders discount long-term thinking or share the common American ideological bias against China. Now would be a good time to use the links at the beginning of this post to catch up to Warren Buffett on the matter of China. Oh, and you also can learn about the three redwoods in the first of those posts.


  "Ignorance is bliss" was a warning to provide for
  the next generation, economic advice from a poem
  America has forgotten but China has embraced

Redwood trees.

On the American Continent two redwood species were well known to the Native American tribes living near the Pacific Ocean.

The Yurok people, who occupied what is now the Northern California coastline before the arrival of the Spanish, regularly burned off ground cover in coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) forests to bolster tanoak populations from which they harvested acorns and to boost populations of useful plant species such as those for medicine or basketmaking.

Inland in the Sierra Nevada mountains Native American names for the giant redwood (Sequoiadendron giganteum)  include wawona, toos-pung-ish and hea-mi-withic, the latter two in the language of the Tule River Tribe.

According to the National Park Service:

    The Spanish padres of Portola's Expedition probably first saw the redwoods in 1769 during their travels of exploration and colonization along the coast of what is now California. They called the trees "Palo Colorado," meaning red trees or redwood because of the bright red color of the heartwood.
    The discovery that the redwood was a new botanical species was made by Archibald Menzies, botanist with the Vancouver Expedition in 1794.  It was not until 1823, however, that A. B. Lambert, an English botanist, first gave it a scientific name by publishing a description that placed the tree in the same genus as bald cypress, Taxodium. Since he thought that it closely resembled that species, he called the new tree Taxodium sempervirens.
    Steven Endlicher, a German botanist, decided that specimens he had studied represented an entirely new genus and in 1847 renamed it Sequoia but retained the species name of sempervirens.
    The giant sequoia was not discovered until at least 64 years after the redwood. ...The Joseph R. Walker exploration party saw the giant sequoias in 1833 in either the Merced or the Tuolumne Grove of Yosemite National Park. The discovery was not publicized at first except in the journal of the expedition.... In 1852, when A. T. Dowd reported on his observations of the trees in what is now the Calaveras Grove, many fantastic stories quickly spread of the apparently impossible bulk of the trees. They were immediately called "Mammoth Trees" or "Big Trees" because of their immense size. All early tales of the great size of the trees were considered as exaggerations, and whenever scores of feet were discussed the listener thought that inches were meant.

One other species of redwood lives today, the dawn redwood (Metasequoia glyptostroboides), native to Lichuan, a county-level city of the Enshi Tujia and Miao Autonomous Prefecture, in southwestern Hubei province of China, an area which was home to sophisticated Neolithic cultures whose members were undoubtedly aware of their special forests.


Who "discovered" the Metasequoia glyptostroboides is a tale well told in a Landscape Architect Magazine story The Metasequoia Mystery. The modern discovery of the dawn redwood as a species occurred amidst China’s defensive war against Japan's brutal invasion which began in September 1931 and continued through World War II ending in 1945, followed by China's subsequent civil war and the Cultural Revolution. Truth has a way of getting lost in that kind of chaos.

Simply put, near the village of Modaoxi, locals revered one particular tall tree and used it for medicinal purposes calling it shuisha. They had built a small mud-and-tile temple at its base in deference to its height and perceived protective properties. On the morning of July 21, 1943, Prof. Zhan Wang, then forest administrator of the Central Forestry Experiment Institute’s new forestry survey department, gathered more than 10 tree specimens—needled branches and 10 stemmed cones, the latter collected from the temple’s tiled roof—and subsequently noted that it was "a new species.”

The coast redwoods and giant redwoods in California. The dawn redwoods in Hubei.

These three species are what's left of numerous species of Sequoioideae which the fossil record shows lived over a massive range in the Arctic Circle, Europe, North America, and Asia. As do humans today. Climate change reduced the range and the number of Sequoioideae species.

A map of Hubei was included above, but not one of California. Even though Hubei is larger in population than any U.S. state, larger in area than 33 of the U.S. states, and larger in GDP than 37 of the U.S. states, most Americans are unfamiliar with the name Hubei because they are unfamiliar with China.

This blog is titled "The Redwood Guardian" so redwood trees which survived naturally only in the United States and China seemed an appropriate subject to begin a discussion about American ignorance of China, the one some of the most ignorant of us have chosen to challenge in a trade war.


Before going any further we need to explore a commonly-held myth about "ignorance."

About 30 years before the Declaration of Independence was signed, an English poet, Thomas Gray penned "Ode on a Distant Prospect of Eton College" which ends with the following words: "...where ignorance is bliss, 'Tis folly to be wise."

It shouldn't be surprising that nearly three centuries after Gray put those words to paper, Americans have no idea, no context, regarding what he was writing about.

It can be certain that Gray was not asserting the idea that "what you don't know won't hurt you." For the ignorant (who were students he was observing at Eton, his alma mater), he warned in the poem:


While some on earnest business bent
    Their murmuring labours ply
'Gainst graver hours that bring constraint
    To sweet liberty:
Some bold adventurers disdain
The limits of their little reign
    And unknown regions dare descry:
Still as they run they look behind,
They hear a voice in every wind,
    And snatch a fearful joy.
...
No sense have they of ills to come,
    Nor care beyond to-day:
Yet see how all around 'em wait
The ministers of human fate,
    And black Misfortune's baleful train!
...
Thought would destroy their Paradise.
No more;—where ignorance is bliss,
    'Tis folly to be wise.

        —Thomas Gray, 1742
 

In this post, of course, we're speaking particularly about the denizens of Trumpworld disdaining "the limits of their little reign" as "black Misfortune's baleful train" moves inevitably towards "their Paradise." They particularly do not understand Asia, and significantly do not understand China, while initiating a trade war with China and virtually every important Pacific nation.

In a 2015 poll when asked if they think China will ultimately become the world’s top national power, 48% of Americans said this will never happen. On the other hand, only 16% of Chinese said it won’t happen and 67% of thought their country has supplanted the U.S. or will in the near future.1

The importance of understanding China just because it has the largest population in the world would seem like a "no-brainer."  And, by most other measures of what makes a world power, China ends up on top, including having the world's largest economy. As noted in a recent Bloomberg article:

    In other words, not only is China already the world’s largest economy, the gap between it and the U.S. can be expected to grow even wider. This continues to be borne out in the growth statistics -- though China has slowed in recent years, its economy continues to expand at a rate of more than 6 percent, while the U.S. is at just over 2 percent. If that disparity persists, China’s economy will be double that of the U.S. in less than two decades.

It is a fact that Americans really don't know much about modern China. It isn't surprising because of a significant language issue. While English isn't a "Romance language" derived mostly from Roman Empire latin, as are most Western European languages it is heavily influenced by the Romans despite its Germanic base.

Asian languages have no such latin influence.

Chinese is a group of related, but in many cases mutually unintelligible, language varieties forming a branch of the Sino-Tibetan language family. Chinese is spoken by the Han majority and many minority ethnic groups in China. About 1.2 billion people (around 16% of the world's population) speak some form of Chinese as their first language making it the most spoken native language in the world, followed by Spanish. (Yes, English is the most widely learned second language and more people have learned it as a second language than there are native speakers.)

Now that might not matter if American ignorance of China were limited to the language or, say, traditional Chinese art. But it does matter that Americans think Chinese government can be understood using the same paradigms that they apply to U.S. politics.

For far too many 21st Century Americans, their perception of government assumes that most often the political person is more important than the system and the policy that guides it. We seem to have conflated these three words:
  1. personage: a person of distinction or importance, such as a distinguished Nobel Prize winner;
  2. personality: based on media coverage of their day-to-day life, a well-known person in a certain field with a distinctive socially attractive character, such as a sports personality; and
  3. celebrity: a person who has a high degree of recognition by the general population, such as a movie star.
Unlike in the United States, the Chinese "system" does not pluck a "celebrity" out of the general population to become the head of the national government. In 21st Century China, the "personage" the Communist Party selects to become the head of the national government has, over decades of work in government, risen through the ranks. Perhaps after rising to the top, that person may become a "celebrity," but never a "personality."

In the United States today, one must above all else be a "personality" to become President or a Senator. Being a "personage" is of almost no import. In effect, because we worship the ideology of democracy and importance of celebrity, we literally have lowered our government effectiveness to that of Italy.

And that is why the Chinese people generally are comfortable with the following statement:

    "We must draw on the achievements of all cultures, but we will never simply copy the system of Western countries or introduce a system of multiple parties holding office in rotation. Although China's state organs have different responsibilities, they all adhere to the line, principles and policies of the Party." - Wu Bangguo,  Chairman and Party secretary of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress from 2003 to 2013

With all of that said, it is true that the outward "face" of China is its President, Xi Jinping, who is currently standing tall in his efforts to provide a stable economic future for the Chinese people. So in the next post let's look at this "personage" who has become a bit of a "celebrity," who during the 20th Century overcame the hazards of a very dangerous changing political climate much as a dawn redwood survived natural climate change.


1Perhaps Americans see national power in terms of nuclear weapons. While the United States does have thousands of them, China has hundreds. The two countries are geographically nearly the same size. After the first 50 or so nuclear weapons hit your country, you've lost any bragging rights to being an important country. Military strength is not relevant when measuring a nation's future power in the world once a country can effectively defend itself.


  The story of China's new leadership generation
  as evinced by the life and words of its President


As noted at the end of the last post, Americans generally have no context for understanding what is going on in Chinese politics without having a celebrity to relate to. Knowing something about the person currently leading the policy changes, President Xi Jinping, might help as he the outward "face" of 21st Century China, a man who standing like a dawn redwood overcame the extreme hazards of the world's changing political climate.

Last year at the end of the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China (CPC), for the first time all seven Standing Committee members of the Political Bureau were born after the founding of the People's Republic of China in 1949, including President Xi Jinping.


All were born and raised in the People's Republic of China. That means that none of them were WWII veterans and none were part of the Revolution. Instead, all were impacted as children from 1958 to 1962 by Chairman Mao's Great Leap Forward and impacted as teens by Chairman Mao's Cultural Revolution from 1966 until 1976.

To understand the meaning of this history to these seven men, one only need to look at the experience of President Xi Jinping.

After the founding of the Communist state in 1949, though considered a political moderate Xi Jinping's father, Xi Zhongxun, held a series of government posts, including propaganda chief, vice-premier, and vice-chairman of the National People's Congress.

Xi Jinping was born June 15, 1953. Based on normal expectations, both Xi's futures looked bright.

But when Xi Jinping was age 10, his father was purged from the Party and sent to work in a factory in Luoyang, Henan. In May 1966, Xi Jinping's "high school years" were cut short by the Cultural Revolution, when all secondary classes were halted for students to criticize and fight their teachers. Xi Jinping was age 15 when his father was jailed in 1968.

In 1969, lacking the protection of his father, Xi Jinping was sent to work in Yanchuan County, Shaanxi, in Mao Zedong's Down to the Countryside Movement. After a few months, unable to stand rural life, he ran away to Beijing. He was arrested during a crackdown on deserters from the countryside and sent to a work camp to dig ditches

Mao Zedong died in September 1976. As with most purged leaders who were not executed, after Mao's death and the confusion that followed, Xi Zhongxun was "fully rehabilitated" at the Third Plenary Session of the 11th CPC Central Committee in December 1978.

From 1978 to 1981, he held leadership roles in Guangdong Province, successively as the second and then first provincial secretary, governor and political commissar of the Guangdong Military Region.

The island of Hainan was administered as part of Guangdong until 1988 which explains the picture to the left, at least in part.

When Xi Zhongxun first arrived in Guangdong, the provincial government was struggling to hold back the tide of Guangdong residents trying to flee to Hong Kong. At the time, daily wages in Guangdong averaged 0.70 yuan, about 1/100 of wages in Hong Kong. Xi understood the disparity in standards of living and called for economic liberalization in Guangdong. To do so, he needed to win over leaders in Beijing skeptical of the market economy.

In meetings in April 1979, Xi Zhongxun convinced Deng Xiaoping, the de facto leader of China, to permit Guangdong to make its own foreign trade policy decisions and to invite foreign investment to projects in experimental areas along the provincial border with Hong Kong and Macau and in Shantou, which has a large overseas diaspora. As for the name of the experimental areas, Deng said, "let's call them, 'special zones', [after all, your Sino-Japanese War] Shaanxi-Gansu Border Region began as a 'special zone'." Deng added, "The Central Government has no funds, but we can give you some favorable policies." Borrowing a phrase from their guerrilla war days, Deng told Xi, "You have to find a way, to fight a bloody path out."

With Deng's support, Xi Zhongxun submitted a formal proposal on the creation of special zones, later renamed special economic zones. In July 1979, despite opposition from Marxist ideologues, the party center and State Council approved the creation of the first four special economic zones.

In the context of his father's work, President Xi Jinping's efforts to open up China's economy are both understandable and believably sincere.

After Xi Jinping (who we will call Xi from this point on) was arrested and spent time digging ditches, he became the Party branch secretary of the production team, leaving that post in 1975, later describing that time of his life: "It was emotional. It was a mood. And when the ideals of the Cultural Revolution could not be realized, it proved an illusion."

From 1975 to 1979, Xi studied chemical engineering at Tsinghua University. As a "Worker-Peasant-Soldier student" under the direction of the People's Liberation Army he had to spend about 20% of his time studying Marxism–Leninism–Mao Zedong thought and doing farm work.

After 1979 Xi had a long career in Communist Party politics and local and provincial government slowly rising (overcoming his status as a "princeling" who could potentially benefit from nepotism and cronyism as a descendant of a prominent senior communist official).

One event of interest during this period was in 1985, as a mid-level county functionary in his early thirties, he led a small delegation from Hebei Province (the home of the dawn redwood!) on a two-week U.S. tour to learn about U.S. agriculture. As explained in a story worth reading in The Street President Xi Slept Here: How a Trip to Iowa in 1985 Changed U.S.- China Relations:

    My parents hosted Xi and his translator, Wenyi Xia, during their stay in Muscatine. Xi slept in my bedroom while my brother and I were away at university, which is why my mother had the empty rooms, and she was happy to offer her hospitality to these visitors from a far-off land. My sister was still in the house and met Xi long before his rise to the top.
    The conversations were not easy -- having to go through a translator -- but both parties learned a lot about each other, both personally and about their cultures and countries. The visit was a catalyst for my parents and sister to visit China the following year, their first sojourn to Asia.
    Life went on and the Muscatine folks involved with the visit lost touch, which is not surprising in a pre-Internet era with significant language barriers. Xi continued his rise to the pinnacle of Chinese politics, and in 2008 emerged as vice president and designated successor to lead the nation.
    As he planned his 2012 visit to the U.S., which introduced him to the world as the heir apparent to lead China, he directed his staff to track down those people he met in Muscatine all those years ago. The staff succeeded, of course, and his visit to Iowa and the reunion with old friends was an international highlight of that trip.

Though you can't tell it from this discussion so far, yes there are women in China in Xi's life. In 1986 a skinny 32-year-old vice-mayor who had been previously married and divorced went on a blind date with 24-year-old Peng Liyuan, a celebrated folk singer, who was far better known than him. The following year they married. Their daughter Xi Mingze, an only child, was born in 1992. She received her bachelor's degree from Harvard in 2014.

Peng, as a popular folk singer, graced dozens of magazine covers during her three decade career, and for two of those decades, she was a fixture on the annual CCTV New Year's Gala—a long-running television holiday ritual as familiar and iconic as the New Years Eve Ball Drop in Times Square. Now, unlike her predecessors who mostly kept a low profile, China’s first lady Peng Liyuan has been in the spotlight since her husband Xi Jinping became president as can be seen in the video below.


In addition, there are women who have significant positions in government in China. But that is not the focus of this story.

In 2000 Xi became Governor of Fujian Province where, consistent with his father's policies decades before in Guangdong, he made efforts to attract investment from Taiwan and to strengthen the private sector of the provincial economy. In 2002 he moved on to Zhejiang becoming a provincial party chief. That year he was elected a full member of the 16th Central Committee of the CPC.

While he was in Zhejiang the reported economic growth rates reached 14% despite his tough stance against corrupt officials.  And in 2005 Xi famously said in support of establishing environmental "green" goals: "Clear waters and green mountains are mountains of gold and silver." At that time Xi Jinping, as Zhejiang Province Communist Party Secretary, was not even on any pundits radar. His environmental statement was far from pandering to the popular thinking.  Zhejiang has pioneered an "eco-compensation" system, which enables regions to both preserve the environment and develop eco-friendly industries.

Following the dismissal of Shanghai Party Chief Chen Liangyu in September 2006 due to a social security fund scandal, Xi was transferred to Shanghai in March 2007 to become the provincial party chief.

In October 2007  the Communist Party of China prepared to convene its 17th National Congress in Beijing. Liaoning party chief Li Keqiang and Jiangsu party chief Li Yuanchao were the odds-on favourites to emerge from the small group of candidates to be anointed supreme leader-in-waiting of the party’s Fifth Generation.

As the newly appointed party chief of Shanghai, Xi Jinping, was not expected to contend for the post. He was expected to continue serving as Shanghai party chief. But at the party congress for the 25-member Politburo, in the ‘open audition’ selection process, for the first time all Central Committee members were allowed to vote from a wider pool of candidates drawn from provincial and ministerial-level cadres. Xi won the most support.

The day after the National Congress, at the First Plenum of the party’s 17th Central Committee, Xi was selected as the sixth-ranking member of the nine-member Politburo Standing Committee and executive secretary of the party’s Secretariat.

Later that December, he was appointed president of the Central Party School – mirroring the path that Hu Jintao, President from 2003 to 2013, had taken during his elevation to the supreme leader-in-waiting position in the late-1990s.

Xi was neither a protégé of Jiang Zemin, President from 1993 to 2003, nor belonged to Hu Jintao's group. His elevation was beholden to neither factional politics nor to the reigning supreme leader’s dictates. This may have been instrumental in his rapid rise to the top

Five months later, at the 11th National People's Congress in March 2008, Xi was elected as Vice-President of the People's Republic of China.

Less than a year later, on February 11, 2009, while visiting Mexico, then Vice-President Xi spoke in front of a group of overseas Chinese noting that "it was the greatest contribution towards the whole of the human race made by China to prevent its 1.3 billion people from hunger."

And regarding the 2008 financial crisis affecting the Atlantic oriented world filled with complaints about Chinese foreign trade: "There are some bored foreigners, with full stomachs, who have nothing better to do than point fingers at us. First, China doesn't export revolution; second, China doesn't export hunger and poverty; third, China doesn't come and cause you headaches. What more is there to be said?"

On 15 November 2012, Xi Jinping was elected to the post of General Secretary of the Communist Party and Chairman of the CPC Central Military Commission by the 18th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China.

On the following day, Xi led the new line-up of the Politburo Standing Committee onto the stage, decreased its number of seats from nine to seven, with only Xi himself and Li Keqiang (who became Premier beginning in 2013) retaining their seats from the previous Standing Committee; the remaining members were new.

Lest anyone think this happened easily, Xi disappeared mysteriously for two weeks in September unseen, unheard, and undiscussed by official Chinese media. The most believable or unbelievable story is that in a meeting of "the red second generation." (the Communist Party old guard's elite and now-adult children) which at the time involved old rivalries, petty squabbles, and apparently fights. When a fight broke out Xi tried to be peacemaker, putting himself physically into the path of a chair as it was thrown across the room.  It hit him in the back, injuring him.

If you think the Communist Party of China is a unified organization of one mind under an absolute dictator focused on evil, that story is unbelievable. If you think the Communist Party's 65 million members form factions and disagree vehemently on policy and that the shift to a new generation likely was rancorous, that story is believable.

In any event, in a marked departure from the common practice of Chinese leaders, Xi's first speech as general secretary was plainly worded and did not include any political slogans or mention of his predecessors. Xi mentioned the aspirations of the average person, remarking, "Our people ... expect better education, more stable jobs, better income, more reliable social security, medical care of a higher standard, more comfortable living conditions, and a more beautiful environment."

In December 2012 Xi made a trip to Shenzhen, a major city in Guangdong Province, the birthplace of China's market economy under his father Xi Zhongxun, and where in 1992 Deng Xiaoping, as part of his famous 1992 Southern Tour, rallied provincial support for pushing ahead with reforms as a means of balancing the power of hardliners in Beijing who had enjoyed a resurgence following Tiananmen Square.

On March 14, 2013, in a confirmation vote by the 12th National People's Congress in Beijing, on a vote of 2,952 for, one vote against, and three abstentions, Xi Jinping was elected President of the Peoples Republic of China.

In presenting this life for context, one caveat must be made. From an ideological view, Xi Jinping is a Marxist. He embraces Socialism with Chinese Characteristics, meaning Marxism adapted to Chinese conditions and contemporary considerations. While that is important to keep in mind, one also has to keep in mind the statements Xi has made outside the complexity of the "system" of Chinese government:
  • Clear waters and green mountains are mountains of gold and silver.
  • The greatest contribution towards the whole of the human race made by China was to prevent its 1.3 billion people from hunger.
  • Our people expect better education, more stable jobs, better income, more reliable social security, medical care of a higher standard, more comfortable living conditions, and a more beautiful environment.
  • First, China doesn't export revolution; second, China doesn't export hunger and poverty; third, China doesn't come and cause you headaches.
Regardless of how one interprets China's social, economic, and other policy goals set in place under Xi's leadership, Americans can consider it all in the context of his life history.

Perhaps that's good, even if we can't help but conflate the terms personage, personality, and celebrity. Certainly the next post in this series deals with really boring complex subjects like economics and the well-being of future generations, stuff that Xi cares about as a human.